California could cut marijuana taxes to lure consumers away from black market
Published: Mar 15, 2018, 3:13 pm • Updated: Mar 15, 2018, 4:52 pm
By Michael R. Blood and Don Thompson, Associated Press
SACRAMENTO, Calif. — Less than three months after California launched legal marijuana sales for adults, the state could consider temporarily slashing hefty tax rates that some say are driving buyers into the black market.
Growers and sellers in the nation’s largest legal marketplace have been complaining that taxes that in some cases can near 50 percent are too high. Many consumers, they say, are shopping in the underground market to save a buck.
Finding a sweet spot for marijuana taxation has been an issue in other pot-friendly states.
Washington state, for example, initially imposed separate 25 percent taxes up to three times: when the grower sold it to the processor, when the processor sold it to the retailer and at the point of public sale. In 2015 that was pushed down to a 37 percent tax at the point of retail sale, plus sales tax. In Seattle, that combined rate is about 47 percent for recreational sales.
In Sacramento, Republican Assemblyman Tom Lackey and Democratic Assemblyman Rob Bonta proposed a plan Thursday to dial back the state tax rates to encourage buyers to patronize legal shops.
Lackey, who spent 28 years in the California Highway Patrol, told reporters that the cumulative tax burden is high for an industry being regulated for the first time.
“Without tax relief to make taxes more affordable, we will continue to empower California’s mature black market,” said Lackey, of Palmdale.
Related stories
- California medical marijuana recommendation provides legal immunity in Arizona, court rules
- Marijuana tourists can smoke it where they buy it in San Francisco
- Op-ed: Welcome to California, Mr. President. We’ve got a few things to show you
- Marijuana advocate Rep. Dana Rohrabacher battling to keep seat in Congress
- Wholesale cannabis prices tumbled in 2017 — and they have yet to hit rock bottom
Criminals don’t pay taxes, check IDs to avoid selling to underage buyers or follow safety regulations, Lackey added.
It wasn’t immediately clear when the bill might be considered, or its level of support within the Legislature.
California began legal sales for adults on Jan. 1 as part of a sweeping plan to transform its long-running medicinal and illegal markets into a multibillion-dollar regulated market. The reshaping of such an expansive illegal economy into a legal one hasn’t been witnessed since the end of Prohibition in 1933.
Black market dealers can ignore an array of state and local levies that push up prices in the legal market.
The state imposes a 15 percent excise tax, then local governments can add taxes, too, which vary around the state. There are separate state taxes on cultivation, along with regular sales taxes. There are new costs for testing and distribution, which could also be rolled into the counter price.
Generally, an eighth of an ounce of good-grade pot, enough to roll five or six joints, sells for around $35 in legal shops in the Los Angeles area. Direct taxes alone would slap over $12 on that price: the 15 percent state excise tax, the city’s 10 percent tax on recreational purchases, and the usual sales tax, nearly 10 percent. Store policies appear to vary on how much of that cost is reflected in the advertised price on websites.
Related stories
- California to Weedmaps: stop promoting illegal marijuana businesses or face criminal, civil penalties
- Oregon officials struggle to ID which marijuana grows are legal
- “We’re going to do something about it”: Oregon’s federal prosecutor holds summit on black market marijuana
- Medley of agencies tasked with enforcing new California marijuana laws
- Could taxes as high as 45% on cannabis bolster black market in California?
State cultivation taxes include $9.25 for each ounce of cannabis buds, and $2.75 for an ounce of leaves, which can also be included in the sales price.
The lawmakers’ proposal would trim the state excise tax to 11 percent from 15 percent, and suspend the cultivation taxes for three years.
According to one estimate, the proposal would cut the cost for consumers at the sale counter by 9 percent, they say.
The state has estimated it would collect as much as $1 billion in marijuana taxes within several years. It wasn’t immediately clear how deeply the proposed cut would reduce that revenue.
Yolo County Board of Supervisors chairman Oscar Villegas said his county has a June ballot measure that would boost taxes there in cooperation with the legal marijuana industry, but said lower state taxes will help.
“The one thing we all do agree on is that no matter what tax rate, whatever structure we put together, the likelihood of this entire system being undermined by the black market is very real,” Villegas said.
Bonta said the proposal was intended to help legal businesses during the transition period into the regulated market.
“If we don’t get it right in the beginning, it will be hard to make up for it later and correct in the future,” Bonta said.
Blood reported from Los Angeles.
Topics: black market, California, marijuana taxes
